Blue's here...
...and Red and Green are here too...
Sup guys. My first Near Pure Good removal proposal as well as my first removal proposal on a good ranking wiki. I've watched the fundraiser videos, and I decided they don't count. Also, the title says it's a double removal proposal because Red and Green don't do enough to be separate from each other unlike Blue. Permission from ZorLink21 to make this double removal proposal here. Let the trial commence!
What's the Work?
Blue's New Superpower is a 2019 YouTube video based on the Animator vs. Animation web series by Alan Becker which is also a #TeamTrees movement. It revolves around the Stick Gang going around planting trees everywhere to save the environment, they also give people hot dogs.
Animation vs. Trash is a 2021 YouTube video which is also a #TeamSeas movement. It revolves around the Stick Gang again cleaning up trash and selling ice cream to save the environment.
Who are They? What Have They Done?
I'll just link their original proposals. Blue's here, and Red and Green's here.
Why Don't They Qualify?
These guys, they are borderline bog-standard. Sure, they helped the environment, but it suffers from WAY too much Fridge Brilliance.
First off, let's take in what we can gather in the first video. They planted trees everywhere and also gave people hot dogs for them to eat. The thing is, there's not much depth in the consequences if these actions aren't performed. Nothing proves the people would suffocate due to lack of oxygen if there's no trees that are planted, and them selling hot dogs is just selling people more food for them to eat, since there's no proof anyone is starving. Also, while they did turn a desert into a whole forest, it's not like anyone is living in them and while it would provide more oxygen, this is, again, never brought up.
Now, let's take a look at the second video. Pretty much, the video has them cleaning up trash in the ocean and feeding people ice cream, but that's it. We don't know if any of the animals in the ocean will die if the trash isn't cleaned up and again, them selling ice cream is just selling people more food for them to cool off their bodies, since there's no proof anyone is severely burning, let alone near death.
Also, they didn't save the environment twice. Going back to the first video, it's never stated that tree life was even in a bad state. While there is, you know, a desert, it's not like trees not being there is stated to severely affect tree life.
Overall, none of the effects of their actions are even remotely implied in both fundraisers, making them rely on too much Fridge Brilliance for them to even pass the baseline.
Verdict?
Cut 'em all. Yellow needs to be cut from PG too since he's also held accountable for the chaos caused by Blue, Red and Green, and he's also bog-standard for the same reasons those guys are. However, I won't remove him since one, I'm not in the PG whitelist yet, and two, SurplusNickle is already planning to do that. So, I'll only take care of these guys.